Who Pays Medical Bills While a Personal Injury Claim Is Pending in Florida?

Graphic titled Who Pays Medical Bills While a Personal Injury Claim Is Pending in Florida showing an itemized medical bill for $17,910, a health insurance card, a stethoscope, a gavel, and a personal injury claim folder.
While a Florida personal injury claim is pending, medical bills are typically routed through PIP, private health insurance, or Letters of Protection before a final settlement is reached.

The short answers

Here is an awkward truth about injury claims: the bills arrive on a different schedule than the settlement. A personal injury claim can take months to resolve, yet your medical bills arrive long before the settlement.. A hospital may expect payment while liability is still disputed. A physician may agree to wait for your case to resolve, giving that provider an interest in your settlement. And sometimes several providers expect payment from a recovery that cannot cover all of their charges.

So who pays medical bills while a personal injury claim is pending in Florida? The answer depends on two things: the treatment arrangement, and what happens to the money when the case settles. A provider may pursue the patient directly or agree to defer collection under a letter of protection. It may also assert a legal claim against settlement proceeds.

Florida law gives hospitals specific billing and collection obligations, and Broward County adds a separate hospital lien ordinance, so if you were hurt in Coral Springs or elsewhere in the county, local rules matter too.


Why does this distinction matter? An unpaid medical bill differs from a claim against your settlement, and confusing them can cost you money. Here are the quick answers before we dig in:

  • Does a pending claim stop the bills? No. Providers can keep billing unless an agreement or a specific law says otherwise.
  • Does a letter of protection erase the debt? No. It defers collection, and the wording decides what happens if the recovery falls short.
  • Can a doctor take part of my settlement? Only with a valid legal basis, such as an enforceable agreement.
  • Can a hospital have a claim against my settlement in Broward County? Yes, if it perfects a lien under the county ordinance.

Why Can a Medical Provider Demand Payment Before Your Injury Case Is Resolved?

Because nothing about a lawsuit pauses the bill. A personal injury lawsuit does not automatically suspend a patient’s responsibility for medical expenses. The provider treated the patient and incurred costs regardless of whether the at-fault party accepted liability. Unless an agreement or applicable law changes the terms, the provider can seek ordinary payment.

That creates a difficult situation when the injured person cannot afford the charges but has a pending claim against someone else. The defendant’s insurer may eventually pay a settlement, yet that does not mean the insurer has agreed to pay the hospital or physician while treatment takes place. Things become more interesting, and more complicated, when a provider agrees to wait.


A letter of protection does not automatically erase the medical debt

What is a letter of protection? Under a letter of protection (LOP), a medical provider treats an injured person in exchange for delayed payment. That payment will come directly from a future judgment or settlement. Florida Statutes §768.0427 expressly defines the term broadly, covering arrangements that function as letters of protection even when the parties call them something else.

An LOP can give someone access to treatment without requiring immediate payment, which is its great appeal. But the outstanding balance does not simply disappear. The agreement may leave the patient responsible for charges if the case does not produce enough money, or if the settlement never happens, so the exact wording matters.

Before accepting treatment under an LOP, then, the patient should understand what happens if the claim fails or the settlement falls short, and whether the provider will agree to reduce its bill. A promise to pay from a future recovery is not necessarily a promise that the provider will accept whatever amount the case produces.


Can Your Attorney Be Required to Hold Settlement Money for an Unpaid Medical Provider?

Sometimes, yes. This is where an unpaid medical bill can turn into a dispute over the settlement itself.

A provider may have an agreement with the patient assigning or directing payment from the future recovery. In some cases the attorney also signs a letter of protection and promises to withhold enough money to pay the provider before distributing the balance to the client. That additional promise can create a contractual obligation separate from the patient’s original debt. Still, an attorney’s signature is not the only circumstance worth examining, as a Florida Supreme Court case shows.


What happened in The Florida Bar v. Pintaluga?

In The Florida Bar v. Pintaluga, 130 So. 3d 1278 (Fla. 2013), a physician treated an injured client under an authorization for payment signed by the client. The attorney did not sign that document, but the attorney knew about the agreement and knew the physician expected payment from the personal injury settlement.

The attorney tried to negotiate a reduction in the medical charges. When the physician would not accept the proposed amount, the attorney distributed the disputed funds to the client instead of retaining them in trust or seeking a judicial resolution. The Florida Supreme Court approved a public reprimand.

The case matters because it shows that an attorney cannot always treat a provider’s claim as irrelevant just because the attorney did not sign the original agreement. The provider’s legal interest matters, and so do the attorney’s knowledge and the handling of the funds. What the case does not establish is that a provider can make an attorney personally responsible merely by sending notice of an unpaid bill.


When disputed medical bills must remain in the attorney’s trust account

Which raises the next question: what must the attorney do with the money in the meantime? Florida Bar Rule 5-1.1(f) addresses disputed ownership of funds held by an attorney. When two or more parties claim an interest in money held in trust, the disputed portion must remain separate until the dispute is resolved, while amounts that nobody disputes should go to the people entitled to receive them.

The Florida Bar’s Ethics Opinion 02-4 explains how this can apply to personal injury settlements. If a medical provider has a valid legal claim to settlement funds and the attorney owes a duty to protect that claim, the attorney may have to retain the disputed amount rather than release it to the client. The attorney should not simply decide which side deserves the money.

Does that mean every medical bill gets paid straight from the settlement? No. The provider must have a valid basis for claiming an interest in the funds, and the ethics rule itself does not create that underlying legal right.

This creates a significant practical problem. A disagreement over one medical provider’s bill can delay distributing the disputed settlement funds, even when you and your attorney agree on the rest.


What if the settlement cannot cover all the medical bills?

Eventually someone has to do the math: what if the settlement is smaller than the bills? The Second District Court of Appeal examined exactly that problem in Frinzi v. Tolli, No. 2D2023-2008 (Fla. 2d DCA June 7, 2024).

The injured woman did not have health insurance and received treatment from several providers under letters of protection. Both she and her attorney signed an LOP for one physician, and the attorney expressly agreed to withhold enough settlement money to pay that physician before distributing proceeds to the client.

The eventual settlement was smaller than the outstanding medical bills, so the attorney proposed that the providers accept proportional reductions based on their balances. The physician had agreed to a reduced payment, but the dispute later concerned the attorney’s alleged failure to honor the payment arrangement.

The appellate court dismissed the attorney’s petition for certiorari because he had not demonstrated the irreparable harm required for that type of review. It did not enter a final judgment awarding the physician the disputed amount. Even so, the opinion discussed the importance of the actual LOP and explained that a court cannot simply rewrite a contract to make its terms more favorable to one party.

The lesson is not that one provider always gets paid ahead of everyone else. It is that a settlement shortage does not automatically cancel contractual promises, so when several providers are expecting payment, the wording of each agreement can determine who has a legitimate claim to the available money.


What Happens If a Medical Provider Sells Your Unpaid Bill?

The bill can change hands. A medical provider does not necessarily have to keep collecting an unpaid account itself, since it may transfer the right to receive payment to a factoring company or another third party. That transaction can become relevant when the injured person later tries to recover medical expenses in a personal injury lawsuit.

Florida Statutes §768.0427 addresses this situation directly. It defines a factoring company as a person who purchases a health care provider’s accounts receivable at a discount below the invoice value.


Florida requires disclosure of the purchase price

When a provider transfers the right to receive payment under a letter of protection, the claimant must disclose the identity of the purchaser and the amount paid for the account, including any discount below the original invoice amount. These requirements appear in §768.0427(3)(c). The statute also allows evidence of that purchase price to be considered when determining the amount of unpaid medical expenses that may be recovered in the injury action under §768.0427(2)(b)(4).

Consider a provider that issues a $10,000 bill but later sells the account to a third party for $4,000. That transaction may become relevant to the amount of medical expenses presented in the lawsuit, so the original invoice is no longer the only financial figure that matters.

Before you conclude that the patient now owes only $4,000, though, note an important distinction. The factoring company’s purchase price does not automatically become the amount the patient owes under the original agreement. Section 768.0427 governs evidence of medical expenses in personal injury and wrongful death actions, and it does not, by itself, rewrite the patient’s contract with the provider.


Why the referral and billing arrangements matter too

The purchase price is not the only thing the statute puts on the table. It also requires disclosure of the letter of protection and itemized medical billings, along with information about whether the injured person had health care coverage when treatment was provided and whether someone referred the patient for treatment under the LOP.

If an attorney made the referral, the statute specifically addresses disclosure of that fact. It also makes certain financial relationships between a law firm and a medical provider relevant to evaluating the credibility or potential bias of a medical provider who testifies.

In short, an LOP is not necessarily a private arrangement that stays outside the lawsuit. Its terms and the circumstances of the referral may become part of the evidence. Keep the timing in mind as well: the statute applies to causes of action filed after March 24, 2023, so the filing date of the case matters when determining whether its provisions apply.


Can a Florida Hospital Pursue Collection While Your Injury Claim Is Pending?

Yes, but only within limits. Florida law places specific restrictions on how licensed health care facilities pursue unpaid bills, and those restrictions matter when a patient is waiting for a personal injury claim to resolve and cannot immediately pay a hospital balance.

Under Florida Statutes §395.3011, a licensed facility cannot take certain extraordinary collection actions before meeting specified requirements. The statute defines these actions to include selling the patient’s debt and reporting adverse information to credit bureaus. They also cover filing a civil lawsuit and garnishing wages, along with certain other actions involving legal process.


The 30-day notice is not a blanket ban on collection calls

Section 395.3011 generally prohibits a licensed facility from taking an extraordinary collection action during the 30 days after it gives the patient written notice, by certified mail or another traceable delivery method, that the action will commence unless the patient takes further action.

Other restrictions apply as well. Before taking an extraordinary collection action, the facility generally must provide an itemized bill and allow an applicable insurer to adjudicate the claim. It must also make reasonable efforts to determine whether the patient qualifies for financial assistance. Nor can it act during an ongoing billing grievance or claim appeal, and the same goes for periods when the patient is negotiating the final bill in good faith or complying with an agreed payment plan.

Does this mean a hospital cannot send a bill or call a patient about payment? No. The statute addresses specified extraordinary actions and applies to licensed facilities, so it should not be treated as a universal restriction covering every independent physician or imaging center.


Patients can challenge hospital charges and request verification records

The patient is not powerless here. Florida Statutes §395.301 gives patients specific ways to examine and dispute a licensed facility’s bill.

After discharge, a patient who requests an itemized statement must generally receive the initial bill within seven days after discharge or the request, whichever occurs later. The statement must identify services and expenses by date and provider. It must also distinguish items already paid from those pending payment by a third party or the patient, and identify any amount currently due.

The facility must make records needed to verify the bill available within 10 business days after a request. It cannot charge the patient simply for making those verification records available, although ordinary fees for copies of medical records may still apply. If the patient questions the bill, the facility must respond within seven business days, and a formal grievance disputing charges also requires an initial response within seven business days.

Why does this matter for someone with an unresolved injury claim? Because a patient should not assume that every amount appearing on a hospital statement is already due from them. The billing status and the supporting records deserve examination before a dispute escalates.


Why Might a Hospital Have a Claim Against Your Settlement in Broward County?

Because Broward County has its own hospital lien ordinance, which creates another issue for injured patients. Under Broward County Code §16-13, a hospital may claim a lien for reasonable charges for hospital care, treatment and maintenance related to an illness or injury. The lien can attach to certain causes of action, claims, judgments and settlements arising from that injury.

This is different from an ordinary unpaid hospital account. A regular bill is a claim for payment from the patient, whereas a hospital lien creates a claim connected to the injured person’s recovery from the party responsible for the injury.


The hospital has a short deadline to perfect its lien

Section 16-14 of the Broward County hospital lien ordinance establishes the filing procedure. To perfect the lien, the hospital must file a verified written claim with the Broward County Clerk. It must complete this filing before the patient leaves or within 10 days after discharge.

The filing must identify the patient and hospital and provide admission and discharge dates. It must also state the amount claimed and identify the people or entities believed to be responsible for the injury. The hospital must then mail a copy of the filed claim to those identified parties within one day after filing.

The timing matters. A hospital cannot simply assume that an unpaid account automatically becomes a perfected lien against an injury settlement, because it must follow the ordinance’s filing requirements.


A settlement does not necessarily eliminate an existing hospital lien

What if the case settles before anyone deals with the lien? Broward County Code §16-16 addresses what happens when a claim or settlement is released without satisfying or releasing the hospital lien. Such a release may constitute an impairment of the lien, potentially exposing the party responsible for the settlement to a separate damages action.

The ordinance also allows a hospital lienholder to intervene in an injury action under the circumstances described in §16-17 and prove the reasonable cost of its care.

Keep the scope in mind, though. These provisions are specific to Broward County and hospital liens, and they should not be confused with a statewide rule giving every medical provider a lien on personal injury settlements. A physician’s office or imaging center does not acquire the same rights merely because it has an unpaid bill.


What Should You Check Before Your Personal Injury Settlement Is Distributed?

An unresolved medical bill can become a much larger problem when settlement funds are about to be released. Before signing off on the final distribution, the injured person should understand which providers are expecting payment and why they believe they have a claim to the money. Here are the documents that deserve particular attention:

  • Letters of protection and payment agreements: Check whether the patient promised to pay from the settlement, whether the attorney signed a separate commitment, and what the agreement says if the recovery is insufficient.
  • Itemized hospital statements: Compare the charges with the services received and check whether each amount is marked as paid, pending third-party payment, or pending patient payment.
  • Assignments and lien notices: Determine whether a provider has a contractual assignment, a statutory lien, or simply an unpaid account. Those are different legal positions.
  • Notices from factoring companies: If a provider transferred its account, identify who now holds the right to payment and whether the transaction must be disclosed under §768.0427.
  • The proposed settlement distribution: Review the amount allocated to each provider, any disputed balance, and the amount the client will actually receive.

Notice the common thread: a settlement should not be distributed on the assumption that all medical providers have identical rights. One provider may have a signed agreement with the patient and attorney, while another may have only an ordinary unpaid invoice. A hospital, meanwhile, may have perfected a lien under a local ordinance. The legal basis for each claim needs to be examined separately.


Contact Us

Coral Springs Office
9625 W. Sample Rd
Coral Springs, FL 33065
Tel: 954-866-HURT
(954-866-4878)
Fax: 954-334-1526


Frequently Asked Questions about medical bills and their payments


Does a personal injury claim stop medical providers from billing me?

No. A pending claim does not automatically suspend the patient’s payment obligations. A provider may continue billing under its ordinary terms unless an agreement or applicable law changes the arrangement. Florida law does, however, restrict certain extraordinary collection actions by licensed facilities under §395.3011.

Can a doctor take my personal injury settlement for unpaid medical bills?

A doctor does not automatically own part of a settlement simply because the patient owes money. The provider needs a valid legal basis for claiming an interest in those funds, such as an enforceable agreement or another recognized right. The exact terms and circumstances matter.

Can my attorney give me my settlement if I still owe a medical provider?

It depends on whether the provider has a valid claim against the funds and whether the attorney has an independent legal or contractual duty to protect that claim. Under Florida Bar Rule 5-1.1(f), an attorney who holds funds subject to a valid third-party claim and owes a duty to protect that claim may have to retain the disputed portion in trust. Undisputed funds should still be distributed to the people entitled to receive them.

What happens if my settlement is smaller than my medical bills?

The settlement does not automatically cancel the unpaid balances. Providers may negotiate reductions, but the result depends on their agreements and legal rights. An attorney’s written promise to a provider may also affect how the available funds can be distributed. The dispute in Frinzi v. Tolli illustrates why the wording of those agreements matters.

Does a hospital lien apply to every medical bill in Broward County?

No. Broward County’s hospital lien ordinance applies to qualifying hospital charges. It does not automatically give every physician, chiropractor, clinic or other provider a lien against an injury settlement.

Can a hospital report my unpaid bill to a credit bureau while my injury claim is pending?

Florida Statutes §395.3011 treats reporting adverse information to credit reporting agencies as an extraordinary collection action. A licensed facility must satisfy the statute’s requirements before taking that action. The existence of a pending personal injury claim alone does not create a blanket exemption from collection.

Medical bills can remain unresolved long after an accident, and the eventual settlement may not be enough to satisfy every provider. If you are pursuing a personal injury claim in Coral Springs or elsewhere in Broward County, understanding your agreements and billing records, along with any claims against your settlement, can help prevent an avoidable dispute when the case is ready to close.