Not at Fault in a Broward County Crash? What You Can Claim Beyond PIP and Your Own Insurance

A concerned woman holding an insurance claim document across a desk from a smiling personal injury attorney in a suit during a consultation in Broward County, Florida.

Written by Spencer Lasdey. Florida Bar #1064640

Reviewed by Stuart G Reinfeld. – Florida Bar Number: 710253

Last updated – November 2026



Short answer:

Your own insurance usually covers the basics. Under Florida’s no-fault system, your Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage generally pays first for your medical expenses, regardless of who caused the crash, and repairs are paid through your collision coverage or the other driver’s property damage liability coverage. If the other driver’s negligence caused losses beyond that, you may be able to claim more from the driver or their insurer: income lost beyond what PIP replaces, lost vehicle value, loss of use and, if your injury meets Florida’s statutory threshold, pain and suffering.

How much you can recover depends on fault, proof, the threshold and the coverage available, and the other driver’s insurer must investigate before accepting responsibility.

For most not-at-fault drivers, the basics are handled by their own policy. 80% of eligible medical expenses and 60% of qualifying lost income, up to $10,000. Collision coverage, or the other driver’s property damage coverage, pays for repairs.

A negligent driver can cause losses that go past those payments: medical costs PIP never reached, income lost beyond 60%, a car worth less after repair, and pain and suffering.


The basics versus what the at-fault driver may owe beyond them

Type of lossThe basics (your own insurance)Possible claim beyond the basics
Medical billsPIP: 80% of eligible expenses, up to $10,000, if initial care is received within 14 daysReasonable medical expenses, past and future, that PIP does not pay
Lost incomePIP: 60% of qualifying lossLost earnings and lost earning capacity beyond what PIP pays
Pain, mental anguish, loss of enjoyment of lifeNot a PIP benefitPossible only if the injury meets the statutory threshold
Spouse’s loss of companionshipNo basic coverageLoss of consortium claim by the spouse
RepairsYour collision coverage (minus the deductible) or the other driver’s property damage liabilityYour deductible, recovered through subrogation when your insurer is reimbursed
Value lost after repairGenerally not paid by your own insurerDiminished value claim against the at-fault driver’s insurer
Rental, towing, storageOptional rental reimbursement and towing coverageLoss of use, towing and storage as property damages

Does the other driver’s insurance pay for my damages?

It can, but the type of damage matters.

Florida requires vehicle owners to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and property damage liability coverage.

That means two different insurance processes can begin after the same accident.

For vehicle damage:

You can file a property damage claim with the other driver’s insurer. Its adjuster will investigate the collision and determine whether its policyholder is responsible. If the company accepts liability, it may pay for reasonable repairs or the vehicle’s actual cash value if it is declared a total loss.

For medical expenses:

Your own PIP coverage generally pays first, even when the other driver caused the accident. Florida PIP typically covers 80% of eligible medical expenses, subject to policy limits and statutory requirements. Our guide to Florida’s 14-day PIP rule explains the treatment deadline and coverage restrictions.

The other driver’s bodily injury liability coverage may become relevant when you pursue damages beyond your own PIP benefits. Florida does not require every driver to carry bodily injury liability insurance, which can create another problem when someone causes an accident and has inadequate coverage.

You can review the Florida Department of Financial Services’ automobile insurance guide for an explanation of the different types of coverage.


Where the basics stop. Under Section 627.736 of the 2026 Florida Statutes, PIP provides up to $10,000 in medical and disability benefits, paying 80% of reasonable medical expenses and 60% of lost gross income and earning capacity. PIP medical benefits depend on receiving initial services and care within 14 days after the motor vehicle accident. Everything outside those numbers is the gap: the 20% of medical costs, income beyond 60%, anything above the limit.

Optional Medical Payments coverage (MedPay) can narrow that gap on your own policy. According to DFS, it covers reasonable and necessary medical and funeral expenses from auto-accident injuries that PIP does not cover, up to the chosen limit, and people often buy it to cover the 20% of medical costs PIP doesn’t pay or a PIP deductible. MedPay is separate from a claim against the at-fault driver.

Property damage limits are shared. Repairs, towing, storage and loss of use can all draw on the same coverage, according to a Florida law firm’s explainer on rental and loss-of-use claims. If the at-fault driver carries only the $10,000 minimum, a costly repair can use up the limit before other charges are paid.


What “more” means: the damages Florida lets you claim

Florida’s standard civil jury instruction on damages (No. 501.2) lists the elements a jury may consider in a personal injury and property damage case. In plain terms, they group like this:

Economic losses

  • Medical expenses: the reasonable cost of necessary hospital, medical and nursing care, past and future.
  • Lost earnings and earning capacity: wages or working time lost in the past, and reduced ability to earn in the future.

Non-economic losses

  • Pain and suffering, disability or physical impairment, disfigurement, mental anguish, inconvenience, and loss of capacity for the enjoyment of life, past and future. The instruction tells jurors there is no exact measure for these, so an award is meant to be fair and just based on the evidence.

A spouse’s loss of consortium

  • The loss of the injured spouse’s services, comfort, society and attentions caused by the incident.

Property damage

  • The difference in the property’s value immediately before and after the incident or, if repair is practicable, the reasonable repair cost.
  • Loss of use during the reasonable period needed for repair or replacement.
  • Towing and storage charges.

These categories describe what can be claimed. They do not promise an amount. Four things decide how much of this you can actually recover: whether your injury clears the statutory threshold, your share of fault, the coverage available to pay, and whether you can prove each item.


Can I recover compensation for my injuries?

Possibly. Florida’s no-fault system does not mean an injured driver can never pursue the person responsible for a crash.

PIP provides an initial source of medical and wage-loss benefits. Section 627.737(1) exempts the at-fault driver from tort liability for bodily injury only to the extent PIP benefits are payable, which in practice means a claim beyond the basics covers what PIP does not pay, not the same expenses twice.

To recover pain and suffering damages from the at-fault driver, however, an injured person generally must meet one of the injury thresholds established by Section 627.737. These include permanent injury, significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, significant permanent scarring or disfigurement, or death.

A bodily injury claim can involve medical expenses not covered by PIP, lost income, and other legally recoverable losses. The available compensation depends on the injuries, evidence, applicable insurance coverage, and the circumstances of the accident.


Permanence is where these claims are often contested. In Dolan v. Negron (Fla. 4th DCA Apr. 15, 2026), the defendant admitted responsibility for the collision and the jury awarded $1 million, but it found no permanent injury, and the appellate court ordered a new trial on permanency and all damages issues. Our article on when a claim is worth a lawyer’s time covers that case and a second one.

Proving medical expenses has its own rules. Florida Statutes § 768.0427 addresses how past and future medical expenses may be established in personal injury litigation, including provisions on health care coverage, letters of protection and the evidence used to establish medical charges. For what an attorney does on a claim like this, see what an attorney actually does after a crash.


What if the other driver admits fault but their insurance disagrees?

An admission at the scene does not automatically settle an insurance claim, and it does not decide how much you can recover.

The other driver’s insurer has a responsibility to investigate the accident on behalf of its policyholder. It will usually review the available evidence, contact its insured, and determine whether it will accept liability.

A police report can help establish what happened, but it does not automatically decide civil liability. Even a traffic citation does not necessarily settle the question of who must pay for the damage. DFS says the same in its consumer guidance: a citation does not necessarily determine fault.

The insurer may argue that you contributed to the collision or that the available evidence does not establish its policyholder’s responsibility.


Your share of fault reduces the claim. Florida follows a modified comparative negligence system under Section 768.81 of the Florida Statutes. Your compensation can be reduced according to your percentage of fault. If you are found more than 50% responsible, you generally cannot recover damages in a negligence action.

That rule is relatively new. Florida’s tort reform law, HB 837, signed March 24, 2023, replaced the state’s pure comparative negligence system. Holland & Knight’s summary of the reform explains that a plaintiff can recover only if their own share of responsibility is “50 percent or less.”

This is one reason photographs, witness information, vehicle damage records, and other evidence can matter long after the accident scene has cleared.


What happens if the other driver has no bodily injury insurance?

A driver can have the minimum insurance required to register a vehicle without carrying bodily injury liability coverage. Property damage coverage and PIP do not provide the same protection as bodily injury liability insurance.

How common is it? A study by the Insurance Research Council, as reported by News4JAX in March 2025, found that one in three drivers in the U.S. are either uninsured or underinsured. The same report put Florida’s uninsured rate at 20.6%, seventh highest in the country, with 38.3% of Florida drivers underinsured.

Even when coverage exists, the limit may be small.

The Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (FLHSMV) describes $10,000 per person and $20,000 per crash as the bodily injury coverage an at-fault driver must show after an injury crash in which they are charged with a moving violation. Claims for the kinds of losses listed above can exceed limits like that.

If the at-fault driver has no bodily injury coverage, or not enough, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage may provide another source of compensation for eligible injuries. The availability and limits depend on your policy. According to DFS, UM coverage is optional, benefits can include medical expenses, lost wages and pain and suffering, and the coverage can be stacked or non-stacked, meaning stacked limits increase with the number of vehicles you own.

You can also pursue the driver personally. Causing an accident does not erase someone’s legal responsibility simply because they lack insurance. The practical difficulty is collecting compensation from someone who may have few assets or financial resources.

Section 627.727 of the Florida Statutes addresses uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage.


What if the driver can’t be identified?

UM coverage is the usual place to look after a hit-and-run. The DFS toolkit doesn’t address hit-and-run claims specifically, so treat the following as general guidance only: law firm explainers consistently advise calling police promptly, keeping the report number, and notifying your own insurer quickly, because policies commonly set their own reporting deadlines. Check your policy’s UM terms for those deadlines.


What if the other driver’s insurer refuses to pay?

You do not necessarily have to wait indefinitely for the other insurance company to make a decision.

If you have collision coverage, you may be able to file a claim with your own insurer and have your vehicle repaired under your policy. You will generally have to pay the applicable deductible initially.

Your insurer may then pursue reimbursement from the responsible driver’s insurer through a process called subrogation. If it recovers the money, your deductible may also be recovered.

The Florida Department of Financial Services explains this process in its section on not-at-fault accidents and third-party claims.


Before you sign anything.

DFS advises checking with your own insurer before signing anything from the other party or its insurer, and warns against signing or authorizing a release of liability if you file with your own insurer. The department also notes that insurers usually record statements, and that if the other party doesn’t cooperate with its own insurer, that insurer may deny the claim.

If the other insurer denies responsibility, notify your own insurance company and review the coverage available under your policy. You may also have the option of pursuing the responsible driver directly.


Your car: where the basics fall short

Damage to your vehicle can produce up to three separate claims, each valued differently.

1. Repair.

According to DFS, you have the right to choose your repair shop. Insurers often have preferred shops whose repairs are normally guaranteed for as long as you keep the vehicle. The trade-off: if you use a non-preferred shop and it delays repairs, the insurer is not responsible for the resulting rental fees. DFS also says repairs must use parts at least equal in quality and fit to the originals, and that aftermarket parts, meaning non-factory replacements for non-mechanical sheet metal or plastic exterior parts, may be used in some cases. If a shop finds more damage mid-repair, it reports the supplement to the insurer and must get permission to continue.

2. Total loss.

When repair costs more than the car is worth, the question becomes the actual cash value (ACV), which DFS describes as replacement cost minus depreciation at the time of loss. The insurer must document its valuation in the claim file. A few rules from Section 626.9743 are useful to know:

  • The statute lets the insurer base a cash settlement on the cost of comparable vehicles, which can come from two or more comparable vehicles available locally in the prior 90 days, a recognized used-vehicle industry source, or retail quotes from two or more licensed local dealers. The comparable cost includes applicable sales tax.
  • Any departure from those methods has to be documented, with deductions itemized in dollar amounts and the basis explained in writing if you ask.
  • A comparable replacement vehicle must be the same make, the same or newer model year, a similar body type, with similar options and mileage, and in as good or better condition.

That statute governs total losses settled under your own policy (first-party). How a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurer is valued is a separate question, so ask the adjuster to put the valuation basis in writing either way. If you owe more on the loan than the car is worth, DFS says a GAP policy may cover the difference when the loan is current.

3. Diminished value.

A car with an accident on its history can be worth less even after a flawless repair, and the standard jury instruction lists the before-and-after difference in value as a measure of property damage. According to the consumer site MoneyGeek, Florida drivers can file a diminished value claim against an at-fault driver’s liability insurer, but it generally isn’t paid under your own PIP, and an uninsured at-fault driver doesn’t oblige your own insurer to pay it first-party.

A Florida firm’s article describes the claim as the gap between the car’s post-repair value and what it would be worth had it never been in a collision, and notes that proving the amount usually takes an expert opinion. The DFS toolkit doesn’t discuss diminished value, and insurers may push back, so expect to document the loss yourself.

Rentals, loss of use and storage.

Three separate mechanisms can pay for the time your car is out of service or in storage.

  • Rental reimbursement on your own policy is optional coverage that usually requires comprehensive and collision, according to DFS. Insurers aren’t required to pay rentals in advance, and many contracts have you pay first and submit receipts. A Florida firm adds that it follows your policy’s terms, not the fault analysis.
  • Loss of use against the at-fault driver is a damages claim that doesn’t depend on whether you bought rental coverage. The same firm says the at-fault driver’s property damage coverage “may pay supported loss-of-use damages”, cites Florida decisions allowing loss-of-use damages for a repairable vehicle even without an actual rental, and stresses that you still need evidence such as comparable rental quotes and the shop’s repair timeline.
  • Towing and storage. DFS says towing and labor coverage is optional, and that before ending a previously authorized storage payment, the insurer must give at least 72 hours’ advance notice. If your car is at a tow yard or shop, confirm who is authorized to pay for storage.

PIP does not pay rental bills or repairs.


How long does it take to resolve a car accident claim?

There is no universal settlement deadline that guarantees an insurance company will finish investigating and paying an automobile claim within a particular number of days.

A property damage claim involving clear responsibility and repairable damage may move relatively quickly. A disputed accident, a total loss, multiple vehicles, or an injury claim involving ongoing medical treatment can take considerably longer.

The Florida Department of Financial Services notes that delays can arise when insurers need to determine liability or assess the full extent of damages. Its automobile insurance FAQ explains how consumers can raise concerns when a claim appears to be stalled.

A few clocks do exist:

ClockWhat it governs
14 daysInitial medical care to qualify for PIP medical benefits
30 daysWhen PIP payments are due after proper written notice, per DFS; interest may be owed if late
72 hoursMinimum notice before an insurer ends a previously authorized storage payment, per DFS
2 yearsFiling deadline for general negligence actions accruing after March 24, 2023, per Holland & Knight

A figure to be careful with: some consumer guides still describe a four-year limit for property damage claims. That may reflect the rule before the 2023 reform, which cut the general negligence deadline from four years to two. Treat two years as your safe working deadline and have a lawyer confirm what applies to your claim.

If your claim is small or stuck, DFS offers a non-binding Auto Mediation Program for bodily injury claims under $10,000 or any property damage claim.

Be especially cautious about signing a final release while you are still receiving treatment. A settlement may close the claim permanently, even if you later discover that your injuries require additional care.


Documenting what goes beyond the basics

A claim for more than the basics is only as strong as its paperwork. Build a claim binder, on paper or in a folder on your phone:

  1. The crash report. FLHSMV says a crash involving injury or death, or at least $500 in estimated damage, requires the driver to “immediately contact local law enforcement”. Reports may take up to 10 days to become available, and the FLHSMV crash report page lists a $10.00 fee per report plus a $2.00 online convenience fee. Reports are exempt from public disclosure for 60 days after filing, but people involved in the crash can still obtain them. If you need the other driver’s insurance information, FLHSMV’s Insurance Request Form (HSMV 83392) takes about ten working days to process.
  2. Medical records and bills, including treatment recommendations. Future care is part of the damages list, so records showing what your providers expect you will need matter.
  3. Income records. Pay stubs, employer statements and work schedules show lost earnings and earning capacity beyond what PIP replaced.
  4. Vehicle records. Photos, repair or total-loss estimates, the shop’s intake and completion dates, parts-order dates, and any valuation documents the insurer gives you.
  5. Receipts. Rentals, rideshares, towing and storage.
  6. Every written decision from an insurer, with the reasons for any denial.

What other Florida drivers are asking

Two threads from Florida drivers on r/Insurance show where not-at-fault claims tend to stall.

In a 2026 discussion on r/Insurance, a Florida driver described being rear-ended by someone without bodily injury coverage. The vehicle was potentially a total loss, while the driver was also dealing with neck and back pain and uncertainty about the remaining PIP benefits. One commenter explained that the absence of the other driver’s insurance did not eliminate their personal responsibility. Others discussed the limits of property damage coverage and the importance of having UM coverage.

Another Florida driver described a different problem in a discussion about an insurer’s coverage dispute. Although the other driver had admitted fault on video, their insurer later raised coverage issues. The claimant had already paid for repairs and transportation. Commenters disagreed about how much the video admission would prove and emphasized the importance of keeping photographs, receipts, and independent repair documentation.

One thread turned on missing bodily injury coverage; the other on a coverage dispute that surfaced after an on-video admission of fault.


What should I do if the insurance company will not resolve my claim?

You do not have to accept every explanation or settlement offer an insurance adjuster gives you. You can ask for the reasons behind a denial, review your policy, and challenge a decision when the evidence or coverage supports doing so.

If the dispute involves substantial vehicle damage, disputed responsibility, inadequate insurance, or injuries that continue to affect your life, speaking with a Florida car accident attorney can help clarify your options.

At RCT Law, we represent people injured in motor vehicle accidents throughout Broward County and South Florida. We can review the circumstances of your accident, explain the available insurance options, and discuss whether pursuing a claim makes sense.

Contact RCT Law for a free initial consultation. You can discuss what happened and ask questions about your potential claim without paying a consultation fee.

Tel: 954-866-HURT
(954-866-4878)
Fax: 954-334-1526


Frequently asked questions


What can I claim from the at-fault driver beyond my own insurance?

Depending on the facts, Florida’s standard jury instruction on damages lists medical expenses (past and future), lost earnings and earning capacity, pain and suffering and related non-economic losses, a spouse’s loss of consortium, and property damages such as lost value, loss of use, towing and storage. Non-economic damages generally require meeting the injury threshold.

Does PIP’s $10,000 limit cap what the at-fault driver owes me?

No. PIP’s limit caps what PIP pays. Medical expenses beyond it, and the 20% PIP doesn’t cover, can be part of a claim against the at-fault driver, subject to proof, your share of fault and the coverage available.

Can I get pain and suffering after a Florida car accident?

Generally only if your injury meets one of the thresholds in Section 627.737: significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability, significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, or death.

Can my spouse claim anything?

The standard jury instruction includes a spouse’s loss of consortium: the loss of the injured spouse’s services, comfort, society and attentions caused by the incident.

Can I claim diminished value, a rental and storage costs?

Property damages can include the difference in value before and after the crash, loss of use during the reasonable repair or replacement period, and towing and storage. Your own insurer is generally not required to pay diminished value, and insurers may push back on all three, so keep documentation.

What if the at-fault driver’s coverage is too low?

Your own UM/UIM coverage, if you carry it, may provide another source of compensation for eligible injuries. You can also pursue the driver personally, although collecting may be difficult.

I was a passenger. Whose insurance covers my medical bills?

If you have no PIP of your own, the vehicle owner’s PIP may apply when you are in the insured vehicle. Check the policies involved, and consider speaking with an attorney.


Sources and further reading

This article is general information, not legal advice. Every accident is different, and laws change. For advice about your situation, speak with a licensed Florida attorney.