
A woman slips on a puddle inside a Publix in Pompano Beach. She reports injuries to her neck, back, pelvis, and hip. The case eventually reaches the Florida Supreme Court, but the decision focuses less on the spill than on what happens afterward.
In Publix Supermarkets, Inc. v. Goga, decided in July 2026, surveillance footage showed Goga performing activities that appeared inconsistent with some of the physical limitations she had described. The trial court found that she had repeatedly lied about those limitations and dismissed her case for fraud on the court. The Florida Supreme Court upheld that dismissal.
The Court did not decide whether Publix was responsible for the spill. The case concerned misleading the court about an injury, illustrating how evidence can shape a personal injury lawsuit long after an accident occurs.
If you slipped in a supermarket, restaurant, or shopping center, you may be wondering whether you can sue. Florida law allows injured people to seek compensation when a business’s negligence causes an injury, but the fall itself does not automatically establish liability.
- Can a store be held responsible for a slip and fall in Florida?
- What attorneys say about evidence after a slip and fall
- What if the store says nobody knew about the spill?
- What if the store’s insurance company contacts you?
- Can surveillance footage hurt your slip and fall claim?
- What compensation can you recover after a slip and fall?
- Can the store blame you for the fall?
- How long do you have to sue after a slip and fall in Florida?
- What should you do after a slip and fall in Coral Springs?
Can a store be held responsible for a slip and fall in Florida?
Yes. A store may be liable if it creates a dangerous condition or fails to address a hazard it knew about, or reasonably should have discovered.
For falls involving a transitory foreign substance in a business establishment, Florida Statute §768.0755 requires the injured person to prove that the business had actual or constructive knowledge of the hazard and should have taken action. This applies to spills involving drinks, water, food, leaking products, and similar substances.
Actual and constructive notice under Florida slip and fall laws
Actual knowledge means someone responsible for the premises knew about the hazard. An employee might have seen a spill, received a complaint, or been told that a refrigerator was leaking.
Constructive knowledge means the business should have discovered the condition through reasonable care. Florida law recognizes two ways to establish it:
- The condition existed long enough that the business should have discovered it.
- The condition occurred regularly enough to be foreseeable.
For example, evidence that a supermarket refrigerator had been leaking repeatedly could help establish constructive knowledge. A photograph of the resulting puddle, however, does not necessarily show how long it was there.
What recent Florida slip and fall cases tell us
Two 2026 appellate decisions show why the details matter.
In Christie v. Publix Super Markets, a customer slipped in a puddle approximately four feet by four feet. Evidence suggested that a stocking float was leaking water, and an employee or vendor was nearby. The Fifth District reversed summary judgment for Publix because the evidence raised a genuine dispute about constructive knowledge. It did not find the store liable.
By contrast, in Kincaid v. Walmart, a customer slipped on a ruptured gel pack in a meat aisle. The Fourth District affirmed summary judgment because the evidence did not establish that Walmart knew about that particular leak or that similar incidents happened regularly.
The distinction is important in a Broward County slip and fall claim: proving what caused the accident is only part of the case. The evidence must also address the business’s knowledge of the hazard.
What attorneys say about evidence after a slip and fall
A spill can be cleaned up within minutes. By the time an injury becomes serious, the scene may look completely different.
Victoria San Pedro Madani, founding partner of Abogadas305, has emphasized the importance of preserving evidence:
“Your injury may still be affecting you months after a fall, but the condition that caused it could be gone within minutes. Understanding what happened often begins with preserving the evidence that tells the story.”
Victoria San Pedro Madani, Founding Partner, Abogadas305
Source: Miami Business
Photographs, surveillance footage, and inspection records can help reconstruct what happened before the fall. They may show when a spill appeared or whether employees had an opportunity to discover it.
Why preserving surveillance footage matters
Florida attorney Rory Safir has written about how businesses document accidents:
“The defense started building its case in the minutes after you fell, with documentation systems designed to help the store and limit what you ever see.”
Rory Safir, Florida attorney
Source: The Safir Lawyer
A store’s incident reports, internal communications, and video recordings may become important evidence. There is no universal rule that businesses erase footage after 24 or 72 hours, but recordings may be overwritten under ordinary retention procedures. Requesting their preservation promptly can therefore matter.
What if the store says nobody knew about the spill?
A customer may report an accident only to hear that the business had no knowledge of the dangerous condition. A discussion in r/publix illustrates why the response to a hazard can matter.
A customer described slipping on liquid dripping from water bottles on an employee’s cart near the pharmacy during a busy Mother’s Day shopping period. The employee reportedly said she was alone, and a manager eventually completed an incident report. The customer later went to urgent care.
The original poster asked, “Couldn’t they have called for an employee?” One commenter questioned why the employee had not parked the cart over the spill. Another described doing exactly that while working at Walgreens when nobody else was available.
These comments do not establish Publix policy. They do raise a relevant question: once an employee knows about a hazard, what does the business do to protect customers?
What happens when a business ignores a reported hazard?
If an employee sees a spill but cannot clean it immediately, the response may matter. Was the area blocked off? Did someone call for help? Was a warning sign placed nearby? Evidence that an employee knew about a hazard but failed to take reasonable action may support a claim.
A separate Fort Lauderdale discussion involved a customer who reported slipping on a wet floor without warning signs, injuring a knee, and receiving medical treatment. The poster also described a manager who seemed dismissive. Replies discussed the difficulty of getting businesses to take complaints seriously and the possibility of seeking legal assistance.
A dismissive manager does not prove negligence. The central questions remain whether the business knew about the hazard and whether it responded reasonably.
What if the store’s insurance company contacts you?
An insurer may call before you know how serious your injuries are. You might still be waiting for test results or attending appointments when an adjuster asks for a statement.
In a discussion on r/InsuranceClaims, a customer in Glendale, Arizona, described slipping on a grocery store floor and later receiving a herniated disc diagnosis. The store’s insurer repeatedly requested a recorded statement and medical history.
Replies varied. Some suggested explaining that treatment was ongoing, while others recommended obtaining legal advice before discussing the claim in detail.
Should you give a recorded statement to an insurance adjuster?
That discussion concerned an accident outside Florida, so it is not an explanation of Florida law. Still, the underlying concern applies: you may not know the full extent of your injuries when the insurer first calls.
Be truthful, but do not guess about medical issues or describe your recovery as complete while treatment is ongoing. You do not have to assume that providing a recorded statement or broad medical authorization immediately is in your best interest.
Can surveillance footage hurt your slip and fall claim?
Yes. Video may show the accident, but it can also be used to challenge an injured person’s account of their physical limitations.
In their article for The Florida Bar Journal, trial lawyers Robert I. Rubin and Mark J. Stempler explained one reason defense attorneys use surveillance:
“It is most effective when used to impeach a plaintiff’s credibility as to the extent of his or her injuries.”
Robert I. Rubin and Mark J. Stempler, “Video Surveillance in Personal Injury Cases,” The Florida Bar Journal, June 2011
Read the article
How surveillance can affect an injury claim
Being able to perform an activity once does not necessarily mean someone has recovered. A person may manage a short walk despite ongoing pain or lift something briefly and experience symptoms afterward. A recording may not show the full picture.
However, exaggerating symptoms or giving false testimony can seriously damage a claim. In Goga, the Florida Supreme Court upheld dismissal after the trial court found that the plaintiff had repeatedly lied about her physical limitations. The Court reiterated the principle from Cox v. Burke that civil litigation depends on truthful disclosure of facts.
Describe your injuries accurately and follow medical advice. An otherwise legitimate claim can be undermined by dishonest testimony.
What compensation can you recover after a slip and fall?
A successful personal injury claim may include compensation for losses caused by the accident. The amount depends on the injury and its effects.
Medical expenses may include emergency care, diagnostic tests, hospital treatment, physical therapy, and medication. Future treatment may also be considered when supported by the evidence.
Lost wages, future earning capacity, and pain and suffering
Someone who misses work because of a fracture, back injury, or surgery may seek lost wages. If the injury affects their ability to earn a living in the future, diminished earning capacity may also be considered.
Compensation may also cover pain and suffering. A fall can affect sleep, mobility, and ordinary activities. Permanent impairment or disfigurement may qualify as additional damages, depending on the circumstances.
How Florida law treats medical expenses
Florida Statute §768.0427 establishes rules for proving past and future medical expenses in personal injury cases. The amount printed on a medical bill is not automatically the amount a claimant can recover.
The impact of falls in Broward County
The Florida Department of Health identifies unintentional falls as the leading cause of fatal and nonfatal injuries among Florida residents aged 65 and older. In 2025, Florida Health Charts recorded 6,665 hospitalizations for nonfatal unintentional falls in Broward County, a crude rate of 334.3 per 100,000 residents.
These figures include all types of falls, not only store accidents. They nevertheless illustrate the potential consequences of a serious fall, particularly for older adults whose injuries may threaten their independence.
Can the store blame you for the fall?
A business may argue that the hazard was visible, that the customer was distracted, or that they ignored a warning sign. That does not automatically end the claim.
Florida follows a modified comparative negligence system under §768.81. Compensation is generally reduced according to the injured person’s share of responsibility. Someone found more than 50 percent responsible for their own harm generally cannot recover in ordinary negligence actions, subject to statutory exceptions.
How comparative negligence affects compensation
Suppose a jury awards $100,000 in damages but finds the customer 20 percent responsible. The recoverable amount would be reduced to $80,000.
Whether a puddle was visible, whether lighting made it difficult to see, and whether warning signs were present can all become relevant when responsibility is disputed.
How long do you have to sue after a slip and fall in Florida?
For most negligence claims arising from accidents on or after March 24, 2023, Florida generally allows two years to file a lawsuit under Florida Statute §95.11(5)(a). This is shorter than the previous four-year period. Different rules may apply in certain circumstances, including claims involving government entities.
Why investigating a Broward County slip and fall early matters
Reporting an accident, completing an incident report, or speaking with an insurer does not pause the filing deadline.
Evidence can also become harder to obtain as time passes. Video may be overwritten, witnesses may become difficult to locate, and the condition that caused the fall may be repaired or cleaned.
What should you do after a slip and fall in Coral Springs?
Start with your health. Seek medical attention when needed, even if the injury initially seems minor. Some symptoms become more apparent after the shock of a fall wears off.
If it is safe, photograph the substance or object that caused the fall, the surrounding area, and any warning signs. Get the names of witnesses and employees who responded. Ask whether an incident report was completed and keep records of communications with the business.
Keeping records after a Coral Springs slip and fall accident
Preserve medical records and document how the accident affects your work and daily activities. These details may help establish the extent of your losses.
A fall caused by a temporary spill inside a store raises different legal questions from one involving a broken stair or damaged walkway. The circumstances matter when determining whether a property owner or business may be responsible.
If you were injured in Coral Springs or elsewhere in Broward County, LawRCT can help you understand whether the circumstances support a premises liability claim and what evidence may matter. You do not have to know whether you have a lawsuit before asking about your rights.
Coral Springs, FL 33065
Tel: 954-866-HURT
(954-866-4878)
Fax: 954-334-1526
